Tue. Mar 21st, 2023
How the Privatization of Eletrobras May Lead To an Uncertain Future in Brazils Energy Transition and Favor Price Increase to the End-Consumer
Brazil’s then-President Jair Bolsonaro launched the sale of shares of Eletrobras, the most important firm within the electrical energy sector in Brazil, which might be privatized by means of its capitalization. CREDIT: Alan Santos/PR-Public Photographs
  • Opinion by Victoria Barreto Vieira do Prado (the big apple)
  • Inter Press Service

It’s because the regulation that was handed to make this occur raises vital dangers to the decarbonization of the nation’s energy sector and has the potential to extend electrical energy tariffs.

How the authorized course of that open the door for the federal government’s controlling stake on Eletrobras raised questions in regards to the power transition

The federal government’s dilution of its participation as Eletrobras’ main shareholder required authorized approval in congress, consolidated by means of a regulation now generally generally known as Eletrobras’ privatization law (Legislation 14.182/2021).

Given how politically charged this regulation is and the electoral dynamics attributable to looming presidential elections within the following yr (2022), the federal government determined to fast-track this invoice in congress beneath a mechanism generally known as a provisional measure (medida provisória), thus expediting its approval course of. The deadline for approval of payments utilizing this fast-track provision is of 120 days.

Whereas an efficient legislative instrument, the usage of this fast-track provision on this regulation was criticized by some establishments in Brazil as not “conducive to the timeframe required to conduct a comprehensive study” that the privatization of an organization like Eletrobras would have merited.

The invoice was authorised on the eve of the fast-track deadline for its approval. Nonetheless, it contained over 500 amendments, a lot of which have been unrelated to the corporate’s privatization.

This technique is named jabuti, the place legislators make the most of the provisional measure’s fast-paced traits to include amendments which may favor their own political interests. By including amendments to key clauses of the invoice, as was achieved in Eletrobras’ privatization, the chance of vetoing the added amendments is near null.

Of all of the amendments to the Eletrobras’ privatization regulation, the obligatory set up of 8 GW of additional thermal gas power capacity to be deployed between 2026 and 2030 was maybe essentially the most troublesome. To grasp how large that is, this provision in idea forces Brazil to increase pure gasoline put in capability by 56% per cent from around 14.3 GW in 2021.

Whereas this measure gave no duty to Eletrobras for the deployment of this thermal capability, it indicators the federal government’s route and ambition for the facility sector. As well as, this modification included a provision that the brand new thermal energy crops needed to perform always for 70% of the time throughout the next 15 years.

Such obligatory use for thermal sooner or later, would end result if adopted by means of, in an anticipated 33% improve of greenhouse gasoline emissions and redraw the nation’s electrical energy matrix which is presently one of many cleanest globally with 82.9% renewables (world average being 28.6%).

The regulation, as authorised at present, additionally disfavors renewable sources, presently the most affordable type of power in Brazil, which haven’t any further variable prices of operation to gas the facility grid.

The brand new regulation necessities might improve set up prices by as much as R$ 6.6 billon (roughly USD 1.3 billion) when in comparison with the prior Brazilian nationwide power growth technique and thus replicate in value will increase for the end-consumer. A requirement to function the thermal powerplants for 70% of the time has destructive implications for the long run improvement of non-hydropower renewables provided that it reduces wind and solar energy capability growth in as much as 12 GW and 3.5 GW until 2030, respectively.

The regulation doesn’t considerably have an effect on hydropower capability growth (already projected to decelerate), which might improve modestly in about 0.2 GW in the same time frame and stay chargeable for one of many largest shares of the Brazilian energy combine.

The affect of this construct up in thermal energy in Brazil

The inclusion of gas-powered crops is meant to handle power safety and assist the corporate’s effectivity in offering dependable power nationwide as frequent droughts threaten hydropower capability. Whereas comprehensible as an goal, because it stands, the present provisions are problematic in lots of fronts, not solely by way of the GHG emission implications.

Based on the regulation’s provisions, the obligatory areas the place these thermal powerplants are to be put in are principally in water-abundant areas. Second the pure gasoline infrastructure is missing. Third, further infrastructure investments might result in larger power costs for the end-consumer.

Gasoline feeding these energy crops will principally come from Brazil’s southeast area to be transported throughout the nation, which provides to transportation prices and emissions. By way of this lens, the government-issued Ten-Yr Power Plan (PDE 2031) acknowledges the problem and prices of implementation as a result of needed added infrastructure necessities. The report implies that assembly the mandated targets could also be difficult. This was mirrored in October 2022 auctions by which 1.17 GW of further capability for gas-powered energy crops have been contracted at a value seven times higher than those bided at similar auctions in previous years.

As well as, the implementation of recent powerplants would require a long time of on-going operation to make sure full amortization of prices. This will result in stranded belongings as demand for cleaner sources of energies outpace fossil fuels. Though the federal government has claimed that a part of the extra put in capability might be used to switch current thermal energy crops (to be switched off by 2024), emissions from further infrastructure and the 70% intermittency requirement outpace the effectivity features from the brand new installations.

That is bolstered when added to the extra requirement of creating 721 kilometers of transmission lines in the Amazon Rainforest region, 125 kilometers of which are located in indigenous land. This means further infrastructure prices and extra emissions (linked to deforestation). Equally troublesome is that such buildup of infrastructure in the Amazon Rainforest and disregard to social and environmental licenses infringes on Brazil’s Sustainable Development Goals, thus additionally going towards nationwide power planning.

Even whether it is within the regulation, will Brazil’s have the ability to entice capital for pure gasoline energy crops?

Whereas technically enforceable by the Eletrobras’ regulation, many questions stay on whether or not firms might be keen to spend money on capital-intensive initiatives which can quickly develop into stranded – particularly when penalties for doing in any other case stay unclear.

As well as, it’s unlikely that Eletrobras’ new shareholders can be on board with such an enormous of buildout in thermal energy crops. Singapore’s sovereign fund, GIC; Canadian pension fund, CPPIB; and, Brazilian Funding Administration firm, 3G Radar, every maintain round 11% of Eletrobras.

All of those monetary actors have proven appreciable pursuits in the direction of investing within the power transition and decarbonizing their portfolios. It’s thus believed that this might hinder their willingness in investing in high-cost gasoline energy crops which require further infrastructure investments to be able to develop into worthwhile, to not point out that Brazil doesn’t produce sufficient pure gasoline and thus may must be imported by way of very costly LNG.

Regardless, if the extra capability of 8 GW of thermal gasoline energy does undergo, one ought to count on these energy crops to be operating for a significantly very long time to be able to totally amortize the investments. This might result in a 33% emission increase which can decelerate the Brazilian authorities’s power transition technique.

Lula, Brazil’s new president, has indicated that its authorities will revise this 8 GW mandate, an try to take away the 70% inflexibility requirement. As a substitute, the brand new authorities may make the additional power as back-up for renewable energy intermittence, diminishing the potential environmental hinderance foreseen within the regulation. So as to take action, a brand new movement must be authorised in congress – a often time-intensive measure. This regulatory uncertainty might within the meantime lower power investments and affect the tempo of the power transition.

The Eletrobras regulation additionally pushed for renewables

The Eletrobras regulation did promote measures which favor the power transition. Nonetheless, if all these necessities are fulfilled, they might additionally improve electrical energy costs for the top customers.

The regulation dictated new concessions for hydropower generation for the next 30 years, making certain dispatchable renewable power, which contributes to the nation’s power transition. Nonetheless, it favors hydropower crops which fall beneath the value quota regime, allowing them to sell the generated electricity under market prices rather than through imposed limits by the national electricity agency (ANEEL). This will result in larger tariff costs, which might attain R$ 167/MWh in 2051 (compared to R$ 93/MWh today). The federal government tried to curtail this by mandating that half of the income generated by means of Eletrobras’ privatization shall be directed to diminishing the tariff improve. Regardless of this measure, this might nonetheless represent up to eight times less than the required funding wanted to maintain costs low.

An extra measure promotes the event of small hydropower crops, to be developed over the following 20 years. Whereas this promotes dispatchable renewable power and addresses the necessity to substitute current previous hydro powerplants which might quickly stop operations, it additionally favors the most costly type of renewable power obtainable, once more creating potential value impacts for the end-consumer. The federal government addressed this by making a value cap in accordance with 2019 public sale costs adjusted to inflation (R$ 314.55 / MWh). These costs stay 7.7% larger than these present in 2021 auctions.

The federal government additionally included the extension of PROINFA by 20 years. PROINFA is a governmental program established between 2002 and 2022 which created subsidies for biomass and small hydro energy crops, wind, and photo voltaic farm homeowners to be able to incentivize the manufacturing of renewable power sources within the nation.

Whereas constructive in idea, such extension would solely favor earlier contracts versus a structural revision of the Brazilian energy grid and prices of renewable applied sciences. Most of those investments have already been amortized and value of know-how has decreased considerably.

Its affect in selling the power transition subsequently, could be questioned, as it’s not essentially deploying new renewable applied sciences, however moderately favoring outdated contracts at larger prices. A extra fascinating different as an alternative would have been to advertise the growth of recent low-cost renewable power initiatives by means of new auctions.

Closing ideas: The Combined End result of Electrobras’ privatization Legislation

In conclusion, it’s unclear what affect will Eletrobras’ privatization really incur for the nation’s power transition. It’s argued that by means of its privatization, the corporate will now be free of forms, permitting it to hurry up investments and improve its means to spend money on new (riskier) clear applied sciences.

Eletrobras’ CEO, has been recognized for his inclination in the direction of inexperienced applied sciences and has advocated for inexperienced hydrogen investments in several occasions. The identical is anticipated from the brand new shareholders, who’ve been seen to undertake decarbonization funding methods. Eletrobras’ net zero strategies across scope 1, 2, and 3 are additionally contradictory to precisely the amendments of the regulation, claiming to decarbonize by means of the gross sales of thermal-powered power plants and I-REC purchases.

Nonetheless, you will need to observe that the regulation does push for thermal gasoline growth, which, if happens, might shift and delay Brazil’s power transition. The absence of clear penalizations and accountability makes it unclear on whether or not the extra capability of 8 GW of thermal gasoline powerplants will certainly be adopted.

Whereas it’s unclear how a lot the privatization will really affect the power transition, improve in tariff costs could also be doubtless. The regulation and the following auctions since its approval, appear to favor expensive renewable contracts, which can doubtless improve tariffs for the end-consumer. Tariff will increase may occur as a result of growth of PROINFA, promotion of small hydro energy crops, and implied value of needed added infrastructure for thermal gas-powered crops.

Victoria Barreto Vieira do Prado is a MSc. Sustainability Administration scholar at Columbia College. Previous to her research, she has labored within the improvement of the Brazilian Voluntary Carbon Market by way of her work at Carbonext, and within the decarbonization methods of main gamers within the Brazilian hard-to-abate sectors as a marketing consultant


ANEEEL. (2022)(A). Três usinas a gás natural são licitadas em Leilão de Reserva de Capacidade. Gov.br. Retrieved October 30th.

ANEEEL. (2022)(B). Resultados do Leilão – LEILÃO DE GERAÇÃO ANEEL Nº 008/2022 – Resumo Vendedor 02° LEILÃO DE RESERVA DE CAPACIDADE – ENERGIA. Epe.br. Retrieved Janyary 7th

CCEE. (2022). Resultados Leilão ANEEL Outubro 2022. CCEE. Retrieved from November 1st

Eletrobras (2022)(A). Apresentação de resultados 2T22. RI Eletrobras. Retrieved October 24th, 2022

Eletrobras (2022)(B). Estretatégica Climática. Portal Eletrobras. Retrieved January 7th, 2023

Empresa de Pesquisa Energética; Ministério de Minas e Energia. (2022). Plano Decenal de Expansão de Energia. Gov.br. Retrieved October 25th

Epbr. (2022). Primeiro leilão de térmicas da MP da Eletrobras não interioriza o gás. PSE Unicamp. Retrieved October, 30th, 2022

Instituto Escolhas; Escopo Energia. (August 2021). Relatório desestatização da Eletrobras: Impactos no planejamento do setor elétrico. Escolhas.org. Retrieved October 24th, 2022

Ministério de Minas e Energia. (2022). Visão do MME sobre os impactos da capitalização da Eletrobras. Gov.br. Retrieved October, 30th, 2022

Pamplona, Nicola. (2022). Eletrobras decide sair de carvão e desmobilizar térmicas mais poluentes.Folha de S. Paulo. Retrieved January, 7th, 2023

Ramalho, André. (2022). Tolmasquim defende térmicas flexíveis e vê renováveis como soft power para o Brasil. Epbr. Retrieved January 7th, 2023

República Federativa do Brasil. (2021). Lei Nº 14.182, de 12 de julho de 2021. Diário Oficial da União. Retrieved October 25th, 2022

Tomalsquim, Mauricio. (2022). Proposta de Privatizac?a?o da Eletrobras e seus desdobramentos para o Setor Ele?trico Brasileiro. PSE Unicamp. Retrieved October, 30th, 2022

© Inter Press Service (2023) — All Rights ReservedOriginal source: Inter Press Service

By admin